{"id":2967,"date":"2013-08-19T17:06:35","date_gmt":"2013-08-19T11:36:35","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/?p=2967"},"modified":"2013-08-19T17:07:41","modified_gmt":"2013-08-19T11:37:41","slug":"%e0%a4%b9%e0%a4%bf%e0%a4%a8%e0%a5%8d%e0%a4%a6%e0%a5%81%e0%a4%b8%e0%a5%8d%e0%a4%a4%e0%a4%be%e0%a4%a8%e0%a5%80-%e0%a4%b8%e0%a5%87%e0%a4%a8%e0%a4%be-%e0%a4%95%e0%a5%87-%e0%a4%87%e0%a4%a4%e0%a4%bf","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/?p=2967","title":{"rendered":"\u0939\u093f\u0928\u094d\u0926\u0941\u0938\u094d\u0924\u093e\u0928\u0940 \u0938\u0947\u0928\u093e \u0915\u0947 \u0907\u0924\u093f\u0939\u093e\u0938 \u0915\u0947 \u0915\u0941\u091b \u0930\u094b\u091a\u0915 \u0905\u0928\u091b\u0941\u090f \u092a\u0939\u0932\u0941"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>taken from e mail forwarded by Sh Ramarao<\/p>\n<p><a href=\"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/08\/army-march.png\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"alignleft size-full wp-image-2968\" alt=\"army march\" src=\"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/08\/army-march.png\" width=\"299\" height=\"169\" srcset=\"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/08\/army-march.png 299w, https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/08\/army-march-139x80.png 139w, https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/08\/army-march-140x80.png 140w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 299px) 100vw, 299px\" \/><\/a><\/p>\n<p>By<br \/>\nHamid Hussain<\/p>\n<p>East India Company (EIC) army in India<br \/>\nconsisted of Indian soldiers known as sepoys and British officers. This<br \/>\narrangement continued when the Crown took direct control of Indian affairs in<br \/>\n1858. An intermediate cadre of Indian officers later known as Viceroy\u2019s<br \/>\nCommissioned Officers (VCOs) were a link between Indian soldiers and British<br \/>\nofficers, however even the senior most VCO was subordinate to the junior most<br \/>\nBritish officer. First World War opened the doors for Indians in the officer<br \/>\ncorps of Indian army. However, only a small number of Indians were commissioned<br \/>\nas officers and this trend continued until Second World War when large numbers<br \/>\nof Indians were commissioned for an expanded Indian army to fulfill Imperial<br \/>\ndefence responsibilities all over the globe.<\/p>\n<p>One the eve of First World War,<br \/>\nthe bulk of Indian army was recruited from northern India. This recruitment<br \/>\npolicy was based on then prevalent \u2018Martial Race Theory\u2019 suggesting that only<br \/>\ncertain races were good soldiers. Sikhs, Punjabi Muslims, Jats, Rajputs, Dogras,<br \/>\nGurkhas and Pathans were elevated to the martial races while inhabitants of<br \/>\nSouth India and Bengal were considered Non-Martial.<\/p>\n<p>Soldiers were mainly from rural<br \/>\nbackground with very little or no education. When it was decided to open Indian<br \/>\narmy officer corps to Indians, British were faced with a dilemma. The more<br \/>\neducated Indians from Bengal and south India had not been recruited for decades<br \/>\nas they were considered \u2018non-martial\u2019. The preferred martial races were way<br \/>\nbehind in education and therefore not suitable for officer cadre. Now that<br \/>\nofficer ranks were grudgingly opened for India, the door was opened for<br \/>\nnon-martial Indians as they had the essential qualification of<br \/>\neducation.<\/p>\n<p>Several factors contributed to<br \/>\ngrooming of those young Indian men from different religious and ethnic<br \/>\ncommunities who decided to join Indian army as officers. The first Indians to be<br \/>\ncommissioned as officers belonged to Native Indian Land Forces (NILF) and<br \/>\nImperial Cadet Corps (ICC): an exclusive club for only scions of princely and<br \/>\naristocratic families. Majority of them faded away quickly and only a handful<br \/>\nlater reached higher ranks. It is interesting to note that the first batch of<br \/>\nfive Indians selected for training at Sandhurst in 1918 had only one candidate<br \/>\nSardar Madanjit Singh from Punjab; the home of Indian army. Syed Iskander Ali<br \/>\nMirza was from Bombay (he was descendent of Nawab family of Murshidabad in<br \/>\nBengal but was brought up by his mother in Bombay to keep him away from the<br \/>\ncourt\u2019s intrigues), Iqbal Ali Beg was from Madras while Tarun Kumar Sinha and<br \/>\nLolit Kumar Roy were from Bengal. Only one candidate Mirza was commissioned from<br \/>\nthis first batch. The batch of five commissioned in July 1921 consisted of two<br \/>\nfrom Bombay (Kumar Shri Himatsinhji and Kumar Shri Rajendrasinhji) one each from<br \/>\nCentral India (Nawab Sarwar Ali Khan), Punjab (Daya Singh Bedi) and North West<br \/>\nFrontier Province (Sahibzada Faiz Muhammad Khan). In view of many handicaps<br \/>\nincluding a small number of vacancies allotted to Indians at Sandhurst, strict<br \/>\nselection criteria, living far away from home, cost of education at Sandhurst<br \/>\nand cultural adjustment resulted in a very small number of Indians graduating<br \/>\nfrom Sandhurst and continuing a successful career in Indian army.<\/p>\n<p>Experiences of these pioneers<br \/>\nwere quite diverse. Review of lives of few of these officers and their<br \/>\nsubsequent military career gives insight into the life of this first generation<br \/>\nof Indian officers.<\/p>\n<p>Some spent only a short career<br \/>\nin the army while others made army their home ending their careers as senior<br \/>\nofficers in Indian and Pakistani armies. The first Indian graduate from<br \/>\nSandhurst Syed Iskander Ali Mirza was commissioned on July 16, 1920. Officers<br \/>\ndestined for Indian army spent their first year with a British battalion. Mirza<br \/>\nwas posted to Second Battalion of Scottish Rifles. He was the first Indian<br \/>\nofficer to serve with British on equal basis and this caused uproar in some<br \/>\ncircles. The issue caused a prolonged struggle among Indian army brass,<br \/>\nViceroy\u2019s Army Council, War Office in London and Secretary of State of India.<br \/>\nThis dragged on for six months and finally Mirza was able to join the British<br \/>\nbattalion in January 1921. After a year with British battalion, Mirza joined his<br \/>\nparent regiment 17th Poona Horse (he joined 33rd Cavalry but around the same<br \/>\ntime reorganization of Indian army was under way and 33rd Cavalry and 34th<br \/>\nCavalry were amalgamated to form 17th Poona Horse). He only remained with his<br \/>\nregiment for four years and transferred to Indian Political Service (IPS) in<br \/>\nAugust 1926. He later became Governor General and President of<br \/>\nPakistan.<\/p>\n<p>Mirza Riaz Ali Baig had the<br \/>\nunique background of combination of family military service and high education.<br \/>\nHe was from a respectable Hyderabad family. His grandfather served as a<br \/>\nRissaldar in Royal Deccan Horse. His father was an educated government servant<br \/>\nand rose to become the first Indian to become Vice President of Council of India<br \/>\nin London. He moved his family to London and Baig lived in England from 1910 to<br \/>\n1923 attending the prestigious Clifton school. He was selected for Sandhurst and<br \/>\nafter commission joined elite 16th Light Cavalry in 1925. For the first time in<br \/>\nhis life he experienced racial prejudice when he came close to British in<br \/>\nmilitary setting. He along with two other Indian officers (Faiz Muhammad Khan<br \/>\nand Sheodat Singh) lived in a separate bungalow called \u2018native quarters\u2019. He<br \/>\nresigned his commission in 1930. He was more of an intellectual bent and felt<br \/>\nconstrained by highly disciplined military life; however his personal unhappy<br \/>\nexperience in the army due to racial bias probably was the main reason for his<br \/>\nresignation. Later, he served a long career in Indian diplomatic corps. Kumar<br \/>\nShri Rajendrasinhji was from the princely Jadeja family of Nawannagar. He joined<br \/>\nthe elite 2nd Lancers (Gardner\u2019s Horse) and had a successful military career. He<br \/>\nwas the first Indian officer to win Distinguished Service Order (DSO) in Second<br \/>\nWorld War. He ended his career as chief of Army Staff of Indian army.<\/p>\n<p>One of the last batches of<br \/>\nIndians trained at Sandhurst in 1932 (commissioned in January 1934) consisted of<br \/>\ncadets selected from different backgrounds. Two were from princely states;<br \/>\nNawabzada Sher Ali Khan from Pataudi and Nawabzada Saleem Khan from Sachin state<br \/>\nand three were representatives of traditional martial races; one Pushtun (Akbar<br \/>\nKhan) and two Sikhs (Ajit Singh and Ghanshiam Singh). B. M. Kaul, Pran Nath<br \/>\nNaranag, Rajendra Nath Nehra, Suryakant Kumar, Muhammad Abdul Latif Khan,<br \/>\nMuhammad Usman and Shahid Hamid were representatives of newly empowered middle<br \/>\nclass in government service and no family history of military service.<br \/>\nBritish encouraged traditional<br \/>\nelites including landlords, members of civil service, police and army to educate<br \/>\ntheir children so that they could qualify for commission.<\/p>\n<p>These classes were in service of<br \/>\nthe government for a long time and in return prospered under Imperial patronage.<br \/>\nMembers of these classes joining army as officers ensured continued loyalty of<br \/>\nthe Indian officer corps. This also diminished chances of subversion by newly<br \/>\nemerging nationalist politics. In 1932, it was decided to start an Indian<br \/>\nMilitary Academy to train officers in India and in December 1932, first batch of<br \/>\n40 cadets started their training. British authorities maintained a careful<br \/>\nbalance in the selection. Fifteen were selected by open competition, fifteen<br \/>\nwere selected from army ranks and ten were from state forces. The first batches<br \/>\nof Indian Commissioned Officers (ICOs) faced discrimination even from fellow<br \/>\nIndian officers who attended Sandhurst and known as King Commissioned Indian<br \/>\nOfficers (KCIOs).<\/p>\n<p>In 1934, when two Sikh ICOs<br \/>\njoined 3rd Cavalry there was a debate whether they should be allowed to eat in<br \/>\nthe mess. 3rd Cavalry was Indianized in 1932 and several KCIOs (Iftikhar Khan,<br \/>\nShahid Hamid, K. P. Dhargalkar, P. C. Banerjee, P. S. Nair, K. K. Varma and<br \/>\nNawabzada Agha Raza) were already serving in the regiment.<\/p>\n<p>Indian officers own background<br \/>\nand most importantly conduct of the Commanding Officer (CO) determined how well<br \/>\nthe Indian officer adjusted to his new role. A confident lad supported by a good<br \/>\nCO was able to move on smoothly while a hesitant young man landing in a regiment<br \/>\nwith bad CO had lot of problems and that invariably affected his<br \/>\ncareer.<\/p>\n<p>Koodendera Subayya Thimayya<br \/>\n(nick named Timmy) was a Coorg; a small tribal community in the hilly area of<br \/>\nSouth India. Coorgs were considered a \u2018Martial Race\u2019 by British. He was one of<br \/>\nthe first Indian students educated at St. Joseph\u2019s College at Coonoor and later<br \/>\nhe studied at Bishop Cotton\u2019s school in Bangalore. He attended Military College<br \/>\nat Dehra Dun to prepare for Sandhurst. Indian cadets at Sandhurst had set their<br \/>\nown rules to counter some of the handicaps and discriminations. The rules<br \/>\nincluded giving double tips, always using expensive balcony seats at the theatre<br \/>\nand not attending the grand ball at the academy just before commissioning (they<br \/>\nwere either unable to dance or not able to bring a girl for the dance). Thimayya<br \/>\nbroke the rule and became the first Indian to attend the ball. He spent his<br \/>\nfirst year with 2nd Battalion of Highland Light Infantry (HLI). He was the first<br \/>\nIndian with the Highlanders but they treated him with respect and his year with<br \/>\nthem was very pleasant. British officers introduced him into the exclusively<br \/>\nBritish social circle and he interacted with British ladies. HLI officers didn\u2019t<br \/>\nknow that Bangalore United Services Club was only for British and Indians were<br \/>\nnot allowed to be members. Timmy\u2019s Commanding Officer Lt. Colonel Sir Robert<br \/>\nSeagraves took his case to the Club Committee but was voted down. HLI officers<br \/>\ndecided to resign from the club but Timmy persuaded them not to do so. In fact,<br \/>\nTimmy fared much better in HLI than other two English subalterns. After<br \/>\ncompleting a year with HLI, Timmy was posted to his parent battalion 4\/19<br \/>\nHyderabad Regiment. Timmy\u2019s CO Lieutenant Colonel Hamilton Britton was<br \/>\nespecially kind to Timmy and once told him, \u201cTimmy, you\u2019re the son I might have<br \/>\nhad\u2019. Britton forced British exclusive Basra Club to allow membership to his<br \/>\nIndian officers. Timmy\u2019s wife Nina spent part of her childhood in France. She<br \/>\nwas pretty, educated, spoke fluent French and felt comfortable socializing with<br \/>\nBritish. Timmy and Nina were fully accepted in British society because of their<br \/>\nunique background and they in turn felt fully comfortable in British company.<br \/>\nTimmy was the poster child of a successful Indian officer.<\/p>\n<p>The experience of Captain Kunwar<br \/>\nDaulat Singh was totally opposite. Daulat was a Rajput from the royal house of<br \/>\nKotah. He was commissioned in December 1919 from the Temporary School for Indian<br \/>\nCadets (TSIC). In 1927, he was the senior most Indian officer with 4\/19<br \/>\nHyderabad Regiment at the rank of Captain. He was a good soldier and intelligent<br \/>\nman but had extreme negative views about British. British officers in turn were<br \/>\nnot very fond of him. He was not hesitant to confront fellow British officers at<br \/>\neven the minor slight. He was conservative and religious and was observant of<br \/>\nall religious rituals. After the day\u2019s routine, he would change to dhoti (loin<br \/>\ncloth) and always ate native food. His wife was with him in the cantonment but<br \/>\nshe was kept in purdah (not appearing in public without covering the face). He<br \/>\nsoon left the army or more correctly hounded out.<\/p>\n<p>Experience of Shahid Hamid with<br \/>\n3rd Cavalry in 1934 is another example of how early experience set the stage.<br \/>\nShahid\u2019s one year stint with British Regiment (Prince of Wales Volunteers) was<br \/>\nvery good. He got along with officers very well, played polo and on completion<br \/>\nof his one year, his CO wrote in his report that if allowed he would like to<br \/>\nkeep this officer permanently. It was a British officer of 3rd Cavalry Harold<br \/>\nWatkis who asked Shahid to join his regiment. In 1922 reorganization, 5th<br \/>\nCavalry and 8th Cavalry were amalgamated to form 3rd Cavalry. Officers of old<br \/>\nregiments (all British) didn\u2019t like each other and even a decade after<br \/>\namalgamation they sat on opposite sides of the table in mess. 3rd Cavalry was<br \/>\nIndianized in 1932 and all British officers thought that this had diminished the<br \/>\nprestige of the regiment thus creating a gulf between British and Indian<br \/>\nofficers. In the process of Indianization, several Indian officers from other<br \/>\nregiments were posted to 3rd Cavalry (Iftikhar Khan from 7th Cavalry, K. K.<br \/>\nVarma from 16th Cavalry and K. P. Dhargalkar from an infantry 4\/12 Frontier<br \/>\nForce Regiment). These Indian officers were not happy to leave their parent<br \/>\nregiments. CO Colonel Julian D Wilton was not popular with all the officers.<br \/>\nThere was no camaraderie among officers and regimental bond was not strong.<br \/>\nShahid had not only problems with his CO but also with fellow British as well<br \/>\nIndian officers. This was the main reason that he decided to transfer to Royal<br \/>\nIndian Army Service Corps (RIASC).<\/p>\n<p>Demands of Second World War<br \/>\nopened the doors of Indian army wide for Indians. In five short years, nine<br \/>\nthousand Indians were given emergency commission and these officers were called<br \/>\nIndian Emergency Commissioned Officers (IECOs). In 1945, over seven thousand<br \/>\nIndian officers were serving in combat arms while over eight thousand were<br \/>\nserving in non-combat arms. Most of IECOs would have ended their careers at the<br \/>\nend of the war but imminent departure of British and need for native officer<br \/>\ncorps for successor Indian and Pakistani states resulted in retention of many<br \/>\nIECOs.<\/p>\n<p>By the end of Second World War,<br \/>\nthere were three main categories of Indian officers; KCIOs, ICOs and IECOs.<br \/>\nKCIOs considered themselves as elite and a select lot and some ridiculed ICOs as<br \/>\n\u2018Dehra Dun pansies\u2019. Those officers who started their careers in the ranks were<br \/>\nconsidered at the bottom of the social class of officers and even ridiculed by<br \/>\ntheir brother ICOs. IECOs were also not considered equals by KCIOs and ICOs and<br \/>\ngenerally viewed as being able to get into the army due to relaxation of all<br \/>\nstandards. IECOs only had six months of training before getting their<br \/>\ncommission. This was due to the necessity of rapid expansion of officer corps<br \/>\nduring Second World War.<\/p>\n<p>Indian officer corps was not<br \/>\nmonolithic. Socially, Indian officers on the eve of independence can be<br \/>\nsubdivided into several categories:<br \/>\n1- Scions of Princely families<br \/>\ni.e. General Rajendra Sinhji, Major General Nawabzada Sher Ali Khan Pataudi,<br \/>\nLieutenant General Sahibzada Yaqub Khan.<br \/>\n2- Young men from urban middle<br \/>\nclass families entering through open competition with no tradition of military<br \/>\nservice, i.e. General Yahya Khan.<br \/>\n3- Educated young men from<br \/>\nmainly rural backgrounds with long tradition of military service. Most were sons<br \/>\nof VCOs but they got their education before entering military academy, i.e.<br \/>\nField Marshal Ayub Khan, Lieutenant General Azam Khan, Major General Iftikhar<br \/>\nKhan.<br \/>\n4- Men who served several years<br \/>\nin the ranks before becoming officers. These men also had long family tradition<br \/>\nof military service but had little education and were much older when they<br \/>\njoined military academy. They were groomed at Kitchener College at Nowgong<br \/>\nbefore entering Dehra Dun. This preparation helped them both in terms of<br \/>\neducation as well as refined them socially to ease their transition from<br \/>\nsoldiers to officers, i.e. General Musa Khan, General Tikka Khan.<br \/>\n5- Men from communities that had<br \/>\nno tradition of military service and soldiers were not recruited from these<br \/>\ncommunities. Major General Ishfakul Majid (an Assamese Muslim), Major General<br \/>\nShahid Hamid (a Muslim from Lucknow), Major General O.A. Mitha (member of Memon<br \/>\nbusiness community), Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw (member of Parsee business<br \/>\ncommunity).<\/p>\n<p>All Indian officers were<br \/>\nwesternized to a certain extent due to the very nature of their profession as<br \/>\nwell as close association with British officers. It invariably had impact on the<br \/>\npersonal life as well as religious outlook of the officers. However, there were<br \/>\nseveral shades of this westernization. Officers from rural and culturally<br \/>\nconservative areas were westernized up to the limits of cantonments. They<br \/>\ngenerally had simpler life style. On the other hand more Anglicized officers<br \/>\nwere as good as any British in their personal life in manners, dress and<br \/>\nfood.<\/p>\n<p>Many religious and cultural<br \/>\ntaboos were broken by majority of officers. Thimayya was assigned to Muslim Ahir<br \/>\ncompany of 4\/19 Hyderabad Regiment. He learned Hindustani from his sepoys and<br \/>\nate their food. Mitha was assigned to Hindu Jat company of 2\/4 Bombay<br \/>\nGrenadiers. He mixed freely with his soldiers and ate their meals. In case of<br \/>\nMuslims, some enjoyed their gin and soda in private and more discreetly (i.e.<br \/>\nAyub Khan) while others felt comfortable drinking publicly (i.e. Yahya Khan).<br \/>\nMany Hindu officers broke the centuries old tradition of prohibition of<br \/>\nconsumption of meat. Musa Khan (6\/13 Frontier Force Rifles) and B. M. Kaul (5\/6<br \/>\nRajputana Rifles) were friends from their subalterns days right up to<br \/>\nindependence in 1947. Both shared meals, something that could have horrified<br \/>\ntheir parents. A deeply religious Muslim Musa sharing meal with a high caste<br \/>\nBrahmin Kaul was not earth shattering in concept but was not common among<br \/>\ngeneral population of India. Many Hindu officers had Muslim batmen while Muslim<br \/>\nofficers had Hindu batmen cooking and serving meals that was almost unheard<br \/>\namong general population. Decades after partition, a senior retired Pakistan<br \/>\narmy officer had some of his old Dehra Dun Hindu officers of Indian army as his<br \/>\nguests in Pakistan. In deference to Hindu religious prohibitions, he had<br \/>\nvegetarian meals arranged in one room and meat dishes were in another room.<br \/>\nLooking at the all vegetarian dishes, his Hindu friends inquired about the meat<br \/>\nstating that they had not come all the way from India to eat vegetables. They<br \/>\nall went to the room where meat dishes were arranged and partook from the<br \/>\n\u2018forbidden\u2019 to their heart\u2019s content. A small percentage remained deeply<br \/>\nreligious in personal life even in their 20s (i.e. General Musa Khan, Lieutenant<br \/>\nGeneral Nathu Singh).<\/p>\n<p>In case of female emancipation,<br \/>\nthere were two main factors; one female education and second leaving the<br \/>\nsegregation and participating in mixed gatherings. Majority of Indian army<br \/>\nofficers were instrumental in educating their female family members. Females of<br \/>\nmajority of Muslim households and Hindu Rajputs were restricted to homes. Some<br \/>\nofficers despite being personally westernized still preferred to keep their<br \/>\nwives in \u2018purdah\u2019 (i.e. Nathu Singh, Ayub Khan). One reason may be that their<br \/>\nwives were not literate and from conservative rural backgrounds making<br \/>\nadjustment to a highly westernized military cantonment environment very<br \/>\ndifficult if not impossible.<\/p>\n<p>During the Raj and for several<br \/>\ndecades after independence, army officers were high up on the social ladder and<br \/>\nmost desirable candidates for marriage. This provided an opportunity of breaking<br \/>\ndown of some social barriers and in some cases even religious barriers. Young<br \/>\nofficers from humbler backgrounds such as sons of soldiers predominantly from<br \/>\nrural backgrounds and from urban lower middle class being the most desirable<br \/>\nbachelors were sought by traditional aristocracy of landlords, nascent<br \/>\nprofessional class and members of the Raj administration as well as princely<br \/>\nstates. We see many examples of wealthy landlords, highly educated aristocratic<br \/>\nand professional families such as doctors marrying their daughters to young<br \/>\nofficers from humbler backgrounds. This helped in breaking many social<br \/>\nespecially caste taboos.<\/p>\n<p>Some officers became thoroughly<br \/>\nAnglicized due to their peculiar background of early education at convent<br \/>\nschools in India (i.e. Thimayya) or education in England (Russi<br \/>\nBilimoria,<br \/>\nJ. N. Chaudhri). Most of them<br \/>\nwere fully integrated in British company due to their manners and some like<br \/>\nThimayya became excellent dancers on the ballroom floor. Some officers<br \/>\ncompletely identified with British and avoided anything \u2018native\u2019. They were<br \/>\nsometimes called \u2018Brindian\u2019. Iftikhar Khan, J. N. Chaudhri and K. P. Dhargalkar<br \/>\nwere representatives of this class. Chaudhri when instructor at Staff College at<br \/>\nQuetta didn\u2019t interact with Indian officers or students. His wife Kukoo also<br \/>\nkept a distance from natives. Their behavior was irritating for all other Indian<br \/>\nofficers and students and they resorted to boycott the couple.<\/p>\n<p>On the other end of the<br \/>\nspectrum, the world of officer corps was opened to the least educated and very<br \/>\nconservative class of India. One example will show the enormous adjustment<br \/>\nproblem for both the Indian officers and their spouses of this class.<\/p>\n<p>Gurbaksh Singh Dhillon enlisted<br \/>\nas soldier and spent three years in an infantry battalion (4\/14 Punjab<br \/>\nRegiment). Light machine gun section of infantry battalions had mules for<br \/>\ntransport and every soldier was rotated to take care of the mules. Gurbaksh on<br \/>\nhis turn also performed this duty while his wife Basant helped him in polishing<br \/>\nthe mule saddle. Gurbaksh qualified for Dehra Dun and after successfully<br \/>\ncompleting his training was commissioned as an officer in 1\/14 Punjab Regiment.<br \/>\nOne can easily imagine the psychological barrier that Gurbaksh and his wife had<br \/>\nto cross as the worlds of sepoy and officer were poles apart.<\/p>\n<p>On the other hand, an officer<br \/>\nfrom a princely family had interaction with British on a different social level.<br \/>\nOne example is of Nawabzada Sher Ali Khan Pataudi. As a child he visited<br \/>\nGovernor House where his family was guest of the governor and played with<br \/>\nchildren of the governor. Such officers were more comfortable and had less<br \/>\nadjustment problems.<\/p>\n<p>One can easily visualize<br \/>\nenormous adjustment problems for British officers. A British officer interacting<br \/>\nwith the sepoy Gurbaksh taking care of the battalion\u2019s mule is now asked to<br \/>\naccept him as brother officer and equal in the mess. The British officer was<br \/>\nmuch more comfortable with scions of princely families like Rajendra Sinhji,<br \/>\nSher Ali Khan and Yaqub Khan as well as less blue blooded but more Anglicized<br \/>\nofficers like Chaudhri, Thimayya and Atiq ur Rahman.<\/p>\n<p>Relationship with officers<br \/>\ncommissioned from the ranks such as Gurbaksh, Tikka Khan, Musa Khan was official<br \/>\nbut not very close in view of huge social gulf. It is to the credit of British<br \/>\nofficers that majority of them adjusted adequate enough for the Indian army to<br \/>\ncome out of the cauldron of Second World War with good reputation. Despite<br \/>\nlingering racial prejudice in all other areas, army broke many racial barriers<br \/>\nfirst. In most cases, if Indian officer was confident and social enough, he was<br \/>\ngenerally well accepted by his British colleagues. On the other hand, sons of<br \/>\nVCOs had only professional interaction with British and due to inhibitions on<br \/>\nboth Indian and British side had very little family interactions. However, it is<br \/>\nquite obvious that the simple fact of British being the rulers and Indians as<br \/>\nsubjects was facing Indian officers of all classes at every corner.<\/p>\n<p>Second World War was a catalyst<br \/>\nfor both rapid Indianization as well as smooth integration of the officer corps.<br \/>\nMany factors such as large scale induction of British officers through emergency<br \/>\ncommissions with no or much less pre-conceived prejudices against Indians,<br \/>\nBritish and Indian officers serving together in combat, good performance of many<br \/>\nIndian officers in war and lead role played by C-in-C Field Marshal Claude<br \/>\nAuchinleck in advancing Indian officers cause helped to integrate British and<br \/>\nIndian officers in the army with very little friction.<\/p>\n<p>The problem of adjustment<br \/>\npersisted even after the departure of British and many struggled to bridge the<br \/>\ngap. Sam Manekshaw caused uproar when he was commanding National Defence<br \/>\nServices Staff College. He remarked that he will not allow any officer in the<br \/>\nacademy whose wife looked like an \u2018aya\u2019 (female servant). In 1947, Pakistan<br \/>\nMilitary Academy was established at Kakul with a small staff. Two highly<br \/>\neducated sisters from an aristocratic family of Bhopal were married to Deputy<br \/>\nCommandant Colonel M. A. Latif (later Major General) and a company Commander<br \/>\nMajor Abid Bilgrami (later Major General). Commandant of the Academy Brigadier<br \/>\nF. B. Ingall made sure that ladies club activities were all inclusive including<br \/>\nwives who remained in \u2018purdah\u2019.<\/p>\n<p>In case of Pakistan, a certain<br \/>\nclass difference existed even among second generation of officers. Sons of<br \/>\nofficers who joined army were brought up in an urban environment and educated in<br \/>\nconvent schools. Naturally they were comfortable speaking English and more<br \/>\nmodern in their outlook. On the other hand officers who were sons of Junior<br \/>\nCommissioned Officers (JCOs) had their early education and grooming in a rural<br \/>\nenvironment. They were more conservative and not very outgoing. Sons of officers<br \/>\ntend to be alumni of Cadet Colleges at Hassan Abdal and Kohat while the alma<br \/>\nmater of sons of JCOs is Military College at Jehlum. There is some social gap<br \/>\nbetween these two groups that exists even today. Some officers complain that<br \/>\npresent army chief General Ashfaq Pervez Kayani has disproportionately promoted<br \/>\nlarge number of officers to senior ranks that belong to his own alma mater<br \/>\nMilitary College Jehlum.<\/p>\n<p>The first generation of Indian officers had to<br \/>\ncross many barriers but it also opened many doors that were closed to Indians of<br \/>\nprevious generation. There is no doubt that Indian army provided a unique<br \/>\nopportunity to young Indian men from humbler backgrounds to break the social<br \/>\nbarrier. In case of India, a native of Madras P. P. Kumaramangalam and a Parsi<br \/>\nSam Manekshaw became army chiefs. Both belonged to the so called \u2018Non-Martial<br \/>\nraces\u2019; communities that did not prefer army as a profession and were excluded<br \/>\nby British. In case of Pakistan, there is no way that Ayub Khan, son of<br \/>\nRissaldar Major Mir Dad Khan of Hodson Horse could have become President, Musa<br \/>\nKhan, son of Subedar Yazdan Bakhsh of Hazara Pioneers and Azam Khan son of<br \/>\nRissaldar Major Muhammad Akram Khan of Hodson Horse could have become governors<br \/>\nor Yahya Khan son of Deputy Superintendent of Police (DSP) Sadat Khan could have<br \/>\nbecome army chief and President if it was not for the Indian army.<\/p>\n<p>&nbsp;<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>taken from e mail forwarded by Sh Ramarao By Hamid Hussain East India Company (EIC)&#8230; <a class=\"meta-more\" href=\"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/?p=2967\">more <span class=\"meta-nav\">&raquo;<\/span><\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":2968,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[19],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-2967","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-articles-2"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2967","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=2967"}],"version-history":[{"count":2,"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2967\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":2970,"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2967\/revisions\/2970"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/media\/2968"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=2967"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=2967"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/patriotsforumindia.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=2967"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}